INSIDER TALKS: Appeasing fans while staying true to brand DNA
As part of the Insider Talks UK lineup of panel discussions at Goldsmiths’ Hall in London last month, Christopher Ward’s Mike France, Studio Underd0g’s Richard Benc, and Fears’ Nicholas Bowman-Scargill spoke at length about the renaissance of British watch brands.
One of the questions they fielded was about how they cope with having large and devoted fanbases, who often feel passionately about the direction that their brands should go in. Although it’s tempting to listen to every suggestion, they discussed the balance that needs to be struck between appeasing collectors and staying true to their own version of their brand.
The trancript of the discussion regarding this specific question is below:
Daniel Malins: The Windup Watch Fair in New York took place recently, which all three of you attended in one capacity or another. At one point there was a queue that wrapped around a whole Manhattan block, with people waiting up to three hours just to get in. These collectors are incredibly passionate and knowledgeable, but how do you strike the right balance between listening to the fans and not allowing their suggestions to dictate everything you do?
Richard Benc: When I started the business, there was nobody in my ear. My product decisions were really just about making things that I liked. Now, people make suggestions all the time. I’m always polite, but when it comes to design feedback, quite often I have to block some of it out. When we go to America, people say: “When are you making a 44 mm Studio Underd0g?” Everybody has an opinion. You have to take constructive criticism, but you also have to keep the blinkers on, to an extent, and stay focused on what you’re trying to do.
Windup, with nearly 200 brands, is a great opportunity for younger companies to meet customers face-to-face. The queues show the incredible growth in interest in watches at more accessible, enthusiast-driven price points. Many Swiss brands have moved higher up the price scale, leaving a gap that brands like Studio Underd0g can help to fill.
Nicholas Bowman-Scargill: There’s that quotation often attributed to Henry Ford: if he’d asked people what they wanted, they’d have said faster horses! Whether or not he actually said it, there’s a point there.
There’s a book coming out next month about the first 10 years since Fears was restarted. There’s a section about a watch everybody kept asking us to make. There were comments on articles, messages on Instagram: “When are you going to make this watch?” Eventually, we made it, and I think we sold 24 or 25 of them. That was a real lesson. You do need to listen, but someone saying: “I’d love it if you made this” is very different from someone actually spending their own money on it.
Mike France: We’ve always been fortunate that a lot of people want to express opinions about different watches. We wouldn’t be here without our fanbase, but you do need a filter. We listen to everything — genuinely — but then we filter it. A camel is a horse designed by a committee.
On the other side, we’re probably more interested in criticism than in praise, because we get lots of things wrong. People on our forum are often the first to spot issues. They’ve been absolutely amazing over the years, bringing things to our attention much more quickly than we might otherwise have found them or put them right.
One example was an Austrian gentleman who sent me an enormous email suggesting that we bring back a genuine super-compressor case. It hadn’t existed in that form for decades. He explained what a super-compressor was and why it mattered. We ended up looking into it and reverse-engineering the construction to bring back a proper super-compressor. It became something fantastic for us. You never know where the next great idea will come from.
When I was a buying director or chief executive in my earlier career, I had a rule for buying teams: no matter who comes to you, see them. Talk to everybody. You never know what may come from a conversation. Throughout my career I’ve been fortunate that people have walked through the door and brought ideas that have led to major opportunities.
The full transcipt of this panel discussion will be published in the November 2026 edition of Watch Insider.


